AI has Mathematicians Crying During Interviews – Lynxotic
Connect with us

AI

AI has Mathematicians Crying During Interviews

Published

on

Speed eradicates worlds. Theirs went first.

On Tuesday a Cornell mathematician cried on The Daily, and then the host did.

Steven Strogatz had come on the New York Times podcast to explain the mood in mathematics after a season in which AI solved the problems his profession had organized itself around. He described the mood as grief, with his colleagues scattered across its stages, bargaining, denying, accepting. Asked which stage he was in, he said he had been dark, and that there had been days when he actually cried during interviews.

Half an hour later he was reading Ecclesiastes to the host and could not get through it. She told him she was not the one crying, and then she was. He signed off saying he would have to go home and lie down.

What had happened to him is simple to state. In April the AI tools hit a wall on the long list of problems Paul Erdos left behind, and the field relaxed a little. In May one of them solved a beloved Erdos problem, the unit distance conjecture, and solved it with elegance, joining two branches of mathematics that had never spoken to each other, in a way human mathematicians could read, follow, and learn from.

On September 8 OpenAI announced that a swarm of ten thousand agents had, in 88 hours, settled a Millennium Prize problem that had stood since the equations were written down. On October 6 the company posted 722 papers on open problems in one morning, and professors reported that the thesis topics and grant proposals of their youngest colleagues had been solved out from under them in a day. Six months, start to finish. Scott Aaronson wrote that in whatever years he has left he does not expect to be needed to prove a theorem again.

The mathematicians saw it coming all summer, and it still landed overnight, because overnight is not a span of time. It is the moment a person understands that the world they live in has already ended. The evidence arrives over months. The realization arrives in one piece, and that is the thing that makes a grown man cry on a podcast.

It helps to be exact about what he is crying for. Not his salary; tenured professors keep those. What is gone is the reason. For thousands of years, a mathematician could be the first human to understand something true, and the culture of the field, its training, its prizes, its sense of who matters, was built around that first-ness. Strogatz put it plainly: mathematicians liked to think of themselves as heroes, and it is hard to be a hero when you cannot be first. At a town hall in his own department, with a hundred people in the room, a student asked what the point was now. Nobody answered her.

Eight days before Strogatz cried, on the other show called The Daily, a researcher who had spent three years building these systems at OpenAI and Anthropic sat across from Jon Stewart and said what the mathematicians had just learned the hard way. Jacob Coxon’s words were that there will be no jobs, and that this is the world being envisioned by the people building the technology. Not a warning. A description of the plan.

So the mathematicians are not a special case. They are the front of the line, and the only group that will get to keep its paycheck while its purpose goes. The internet understood this before the mathematicians did. The joke going around, which Strogatz himself repeated, tells the greatest living mathematician to put the fries in the bag. It is cruel and it is honest. It is the sound of everyone who already watched their trade vanish watching the smartest kid in the class lose his.

Here is where the story usually turns into hysteria, and where it should not. The tears are real. The conclusion people draw from them, that human purpose dies with human labor, is unproven, because nobody has yet tried to live without it. A farmer with a tractor is still a farmer. Listen to the rest of the interview and Strogatz spends most of the hour arguing against his own grief. The moment he actually breaks down on air is not a lost proof. It is a photograph of old Erdos, who had no home and could not make toast, sitting with eight-year-old Terry Tao, the two of them working on an inconsequential problem for the pleasure of being together. The hero he mourns was never the theorem. It was the picture, and nothing in the picture has been automated. A colleague at the town hall said the new tools are a new telescope, and the only question is where you point it. Strogatz uses the machine to teach himself and says it is wonderful. He allows that this could be the best time ever to be alive. And he notes, almost in passing, that there is still no Erdos among the machines, nothing that can pose a good question.

Which brings us to the thing the mathematicians know better than anyone. A proof that is true and that no human understands is not yet mathematics. One MIT mathematician said it this way: if the machines prove every theorem and no person reads them, the results cannot be part of culture, because culture is a human thing. A theorem becomes mathematics when someone reads it and finds it beautiful. What is beauty, unless someone observes it and finds it beautiful?

That is the shape of the whole dilemma, not just the mathematicians’ corner of it. The abundance is coming whether anyone wants it or not; Coxon was describing the plan, not predicting the weather. The meaning is not attached to it. Meaning has to be searched for, the way beauty is searched for, and it is a better thing to search for than mere survival. Before anyone calls the future a curse, we owe it at least one serious attempt to imagine and build the best version of it that human eyes could look at and find good. Not a utopia. An entopic one, a fractional utopia, the best possible outcome judged from where a person actually stands.

The urgency is the six months. The mathematicians did not get a fifty-year runway to find out whether people can be heroes without jobs, and neither will anyone else. The student’s question is now addressed to all of us. Strogatz’s answer, the one he arrived at in tears, was that it is not about God. It is about people. That is where the search starts.

Advertisement

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe for free premium stories and the latest news

Lynxotic Logo

You have Successfully Subscribed!