In recent months, a disturbing trend has emerged across social media platforms, particularly TikTok and Facebook: users are reporting widespread instances of “phantom following” and “phantom unfollowing.” These anomalies, where accounts appear to follow or unfollow others without user consent, have sparked outrage and suspicion. Coupled with reports of manipulated search engine results—where queries return blank pages or altered outcomes—these issues have fueled a growing consensus that platforms like Meta (Facebook’s parent company) and TikTok are engaging in systemic manipulation. The situation has become so blatant that users are actively seeking open-source alternatives, with platforms like BlueSky leading the charge toward a less corrupt digital ecosystem.
The Phantom Following Phenomenon
Numerous TikTok and Facebook users have documented instances where their accounts seemingly act independently, following or unfollowing accounts en masse without their input. This “phantom following” phenomenon has left users feeling violated and powerless, as their digital identities are manipulated behind the scenes. For example, some users have reported logging into their accounts only to find hundreds of new follows—often to accounts they have no interest in—while others have discovered that they’ve unfollowed close friends or favorite creators without explanation.
The implications of this manipulation are profound. Social media algorithms rely heavily on user behavior, such as follows and likes, to curate content and personalize feeds. When these actions are artificially altered, the algorithms can no longer accurately reflect user preferences, leading to a distorted online experience. This not only undermines user trust but also raises questions about the integrity of these platforms’ recommendation systems.
Search Engine Anomalies and Geographic Disparities
Adding to the chaos, users have reported bizarre inconsistencies in search engine results. Queries that return complete and relevant results in one country, such as Canada, often yield blank pages or altered outcomes in another, like the United States. These discrepancies suggest that search algorithms are being manipulated to suppress or prioritize certain information based on geographic or political factors.
For instance, a user searching for news about a controversial topic might find comprehensive results in Canada but encounter a blank page or heavily curated content in the U.S. This geographic disparity has led to accusations of censorship and bias, further eroding trust in these platforms. The fact that these anomalies are so blatant has only heightened suspicions that companies like Meta and TikTok are actively manipulating their systems to serve hidden agendas.
The TikTok Ban Furor and the Rise of Open-Source Alternatives
The controversy surrounding TikTok’s alleged manipulation has been amplified by the ongoing debate over its potential ban in the United States. Critics argue that TikTok, owned by the Chinese company ByteDance, poses a national security risk due to its sophisticated recommendation algorithm, which could be exploited by foreign governments. However, many users see the ban as a distraction from the broader issue of platform manipulation, pointing out that Meta and other U.S.-based companies are equally guilty of unethical practices.
Advertisement
In response to these concerns, a growing number of users are turning to open-source alternatives that promise greater transparency and user control. BlueSky, a decentralized social media platform, has emerged as a notable early mover in this space. Unlike traditional platforms, BlueSky operates on an open protocol, allowing users to customize their experience and avoid the opaque algorithms that plague mainstream apps.
Meanwhile, a wave of new startups is racing to develop the “people’s” version of TikTok—a platform that prioritizes user autonomy and resists corporate or governmental interference. These efforts reflect a broader shift toward decentralized, community-driven solutions that challenge the monopolistic dominance of tech giants like Meta and ByteDance.
Conclusion: A Call for Accountability and Innovation
The rampant manipulation of follows, unfollows, and search results on platforms like TikTok and Facebook underscores the urgent need for accountability in the tech industry. As users become increasingly aware of these practices, the demand for open-source alternatives is likely to grow, paving the way for a more transparent and equitable digital landscape.
While platforms like BlueSky offer a promising glimpse of this future, the road ahead is fraught with challenges. Building a viable alternative to TikTok or Facebook requires not only technical innovation but also a fundamental rethinking of how social media platforms operate. For now, the phantom following crisis serves as a stark reminder of the power these platforms wield—and the lengths to which they will go to maintain control.
As users continue to search for alternatives, one thing is clear: the era of blind trust in Big Tech is over. The question now is whether the next generation of platforms can deliver on their promise of a fairer, more open internet—or whether they, too, will succumb to the same forces of manipulation and control.