Journalists have used scrapers to collect data that rooted out extremist cops, tracked lobbyists, and uncovered an underground market for adopted children
By: The Markup Staff
The fruits of web scraping—using code to harvest data and information from websites—are all around us.
People build scrapers that can find every Applebee’s on the planet or collect congressional legislation and votes or track fancy watches for sale on fan websites. Businesses use scrapers to manage their online retail inventory and monitor competitors’ prices. Lots of well-known sites use scrapers to do things like track airline ticket prices and job listings. Google is essentially a giant, crawling web scraper.
Scrapers are also the tools of watchdogs and journalists, which is why The Markup filed an amicus brief in a case before the U.S. Supreme Court this week that threatens to make scraping illegal.
The case itself—Van Buren v. United States—is not about scraping but rather a legal question regarding the prosecution of a Georgia police officer, Nathan Van Buren, who was bribed to look up confidential information in a law enforcement database. Van Buren was prosecuted under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), which prohibits unauthorized access to a computer network such as computer hacking, where someone breaks into a system to steal information (or, as dramatized in the 1980s classic movie “WarGames,” potentially start World War III).
In Van Buren’s case, since he was allowed to access the database for work, the question is whether the court will broadly define his troubling activities as “exceeding authorized access” to extract data, which is what would make it a crime under the CFAA. And it’s that definition that could affect journalists.
Or, as Justice Neil Gorsuch put it during Monday’s oral arguments, lead in the direction of “perhaps making a federal criminal of us all.”
Investigative journalists and other watchdogs often use scrapers to illuminate issues big and small, from tracking the influence of lobbyists in Peru by harvesting the digital visitor logs for government buildings to monitoring and collecting political ads on Facebook. In both of those instances, the pages and data scraped are publicly available on the internet—no hacking necessary—but sites involved could easily change the fine print on their terms of service to label the aggregation of that information “unauthorized.” And the U.S. Supreme Court, depending on how it rules, could decide that violating those terms of service is a crime under the CFAA.
“A statute that allows powerful forces like the government or wealthy corporate actors to unilaterally criminalize newsgathering activities by blocking these efforts through the terms of service for their websites would violate the First Amendment,” The Markup wrote in our brief.
What sort of work is at risk? Here’s a roundup of some recent journalism made possible by web scraping:
- The COVID tracking project, from The Atlantic, collects and aggregates data from around the country on a daily basis, serving as a means of monitoring where testing is happening, where the pandemic is growing, and the racial disparities in who’s contracting and dying from the virus.
- This project, from Reveal, scraped extremist Facebook groups and compared their membership rolls to those of law enforcement groups on Facebook—and found a lot of overlap.
- Reveal also used scrapers to find that hundreds of millions of dollars in property taxes should have never been charged to Detroit residents who then lost their homes through foreclosure.
- The Markup’s recent investigation into Google’s search results found that it consistently favors its own products, leaving some websites from which the web giant itself scrapes information struggling for visitors and, therefore, ad revenue. The U.S. Department of Justice cited the issue in an antitrust lawsuit against the company.
- In Copy, Paste, Legislate, USA Today found a pattern of cookie-cutter laws, pushed by special interest groups, circulating in legislatures around the country.
- Reuters scraped social media and message boards to find an underground market for adopted children whose parents, who had usually adopted the children from abroad, decided the children were too much for them. A couple featured in the piece was later convicted of kidnapping as a result of the investigation.
- Gizmodo was able to use similar tools to find the probable locations of tens of thousands of Ring surveillance cameras.
- The Trace and The Verge, using scrapers, found people using an online market to sell guns without a license and without performing background checks.
This article was originally published on The Markup and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.
- Leader of Oath Keepers Convicted in January 6th Case
- Love or Hate Elon Musk, The Tesla Semi is a Big Step Forward
- Solutions are Available to Save the Planet: How do we get the Public to Demand them?
- Why Elon Musk Bought Twitter V3: The Tesla Phone Wrinkle
- These Books take a Hard look how Climate Change & Capitalism Clash
Lynxotic may receive a small commission based on any purchases made by following links from this page
Apps3 weeks ago
Billie Eilish Strikes again on TikTok: “Slumber Party” Rehearsal (X)
Apple2 weeks ago
The Vision of Steve Jobs for the Future of Apple has Barely Begun to Emerge
Entertainment2 weeks ago
Billie Eilish makes her “secret” TikTok Debut and the content is…Wow
Apple2 months ago
Oh. So. Pro.: Apple’s new slogan for iPhone 13 Pro is both Obvious and an Infinite Enigma
Health and Diet2 weeks ago
Cider Vinegar Bitters Might Do Miracles for Your Digestion
Books3 weeks ago
Baking for Fall: Bread and Comfort Foods to Indulge the Senses
Apps1 week ago
Goodbye Twitter, Hello Mastodon!
Elon Musk1 week ago
Why Elon Musk Really Bought Twitter V2
Climate3 months ago
Solarpunk: Visions of a just, nature-positive world￼
Apple2 months ago
Best thing about the new Mac Studio Display? It’s Optional with the Mac Studio Desktop…
Health and Diet2 weeks ago
The Healthy Art of Fasting – It’s Not WHAT You Eat It’s WHEN You Eat
Books2 weeks ago
Alternate day or Intermittent Fasting Diets – Can they improve Strength and Stamina?